Thank You for Your Donation:) only $1

March 14, 2024

Data shows how much danger Texas House Speaker is in

Plus: Don't count on a Biden impeachment.

 ͏  ͏  ͏
Texas Take with Jeremy Wallace

Spring Sale
Only 25¢ for a digital subscription.
Act Now


Dade Phelan's bad math problem

Texas House Speaker Dade Phelan may not be as doomed as it might first appear.

Sure, the Beaumont Republican was pushed into a runoff primary election last week, and that has historically been bad for incumbents. 

Since 2014, just 27 percent of Republican incumbents forced into runoffs in Texas Legislature races have been re-elected. Add in both Republicans and Democrats, and the number climbs to 35 percent with just six of the 17 incumbents pushed into runoffs winning re-election.

But maybe the better news for Phelan and his campaign team is the recent results in 2022, in which three of the four incumbents forced into runoffs ended up winning.

To be sure, Phelan has headwinds that no Republican House Speaker in Texas history has ever had. Former President Donald Trump and Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton have both endorsed businessman David Covey over Phelan. In addition, Texas Lt. Gov. Dan Patrick, who runs the Texas Senate, has been trying to help defeat Phelan after the two have absolutely warred against each these last few years over a number of issues. Paxton's grudge is even more personal. Phelan not only allowed the House to vote to impeach Paxton over corruption charges, but has vociferously defended the action time and again.

While the odds are against Phelan, he has advantages most incumbents don't have because he is the leader of the Texas House. He has both a higher profile and more resources to do battle in the runoff than your typical state legislator.

"This runoff is not just another race, it's the frontline of the battle for the soul of our district," Phelan said after the initial primary election.

It all backs up what my Texas Take podcast co-host Scott Braddock said during a speech he and I gave before the Greater Houston Pachyderm Club. He said while the numbers aren't great, people are getting ahead of themselves if they think it means Phelan is a goner. There's a lot of campaigning between now and the May 28 runoff election.

Photo of Jeremy Wallace

Jeremy Wallace, Texas politics reporter

jeremy.wallace@houstonchronicle.com


Who's up, who's down

Who's up and who's down for Texas Take newsletter.

Up: Joe Biden.

It sounds more like Republicans are giving up on the idea of impeaching the president. U.S. Rep. Troy Nehls, R-Fort Bend County, said Republicans have made a good case for impeaching Biden, but it may never happen. "I don't think we have the will to impeach Joe Biden," Nehls told Fox News Digital. "We just don't. We've got a two-seat majority. You've got some guys in these tough districts that don't want to alienate maybe independents or moderates."

Down: Dade Phelan.

The Texas House Speaker from Beaumont is trying to do something that few Republicans have succeeded in doing over the last 20 years: win a runoff election as an incumbent. Since 2014, just 27 percent of Republican state lawmakers pushed into a runoff election have been able to hold onto their seats. It's not impossible, but Phelan is fighting some tough odds.

What do you think? Hit reply and let me know.


What else is going on in Texas

Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton speaks outside the U.S. Supreme Court in Washington, D.C., in November 2021. (Drew Angerer/Getty Images/TNS)

Photo by: Drew Angerer/TNS

New court rule could block Texas AG Ken Paxton from 'judge shopping'

Paxton has repeatedly turned to single-judge divisions to block the Biden administration from implementing policies.

A mobile phone with the logo of Pornhub on its screen. (Photo by Nikos Pekiaridis/NurPhoto via Getty Images)

Photo by: NurPhoto/NurPhoto Via Getty Images

Pornhub disables website in Texas over objection to age verification law

One of the most-visited pornography websites, Pornhub, disabled its site in Texas on Thursday over objections to a state law that requires age verification to prevent access to minors.

Dr. Austin Dennard of Dallas holds her son as they walk out of the Texas Supreme Courtroom with Lauren Miller of Dallas on Tuesday, Nov. 28, 2023, in Austin, Texas. Both women are part of the Zurawski v. Texas case, a major challenge to the state's bortion ban led by more than 20 women suing for clarified medical exemptions. The women on the lawsuit, which was filed in March, say they were denied care and their health was jeopardized because the law is overly vague.

Photo by: Sam Owens/San Antonio Express-News

Texas Medical Board considers guidance on when abortions are allowed

Major lawsuits by nearly two dozen Texas women alleged their lives and future fertility were endangered because of the abortion ban's vagueness.

Houston Mayor John Whitmire speaks during a press conference with city attorney Arturo G. Michel, from left, ASL interpreter Timothyy Herrera and Ellen Cohen to announce a task force for independent suspended case review of Houston Police Department scandal on Wednesday, March 13, 2024 in Houston.

Photo by: Elizabeth Conley, Staff Photographer

Houston Mayor names panel to explore suspended police reports

Mayor John Whitmire named the five people who will run an independent investigation into the Houston Police Department's handling of over 264,000 suspended incident reports. 

FILE- South Dakota Gov. Kristi Noem speaks in Oxon Hill, Md., Friday, Feb. 23, 2024. Noem posted an infomercial-style video on X Monday, March 11, 2024, lavishing praise on a team of cosmetic dentists outside her state for giving her a smile she said she can be proud of.

Photo by: Alex Brandon, AP

South Dakota governor's trip to Texas for dental work causing trouble back home

A Democratic legislator is calling for an inquiry into South Dakota Republican Gov. Kristi Noem's trip to Texas for dental work and a promotional video in which she praises the dental office.

FILE - Tesla CEO Elon Musk waves as he leaves the Tesla Gigafactory for electric cars after a visit in Gruenheide near Berlin, Germany, Wednesday, March 13, 2024. Musk abruptly canceled

Photo by: Ebrahim Noroozi, AP

Elon Musk abruptly cancels 'The Don Lemon Show' on X after tense interview

The move to cancel the show came after the former CNN anchor Lemon recorded an interview with the billionaire for the show's as-yet unaired first episode.


Pick of the day

10

Photo by: Jeremy Wallace

That is the number of additional campuses the state's largest charter school network will be able to open in Texas, despite being put under conservatorship for misusing public funds. Reporter Edward McKinley writes that IDEA Public Schools is allowed to increase student enrollment from 78,200 to more than 90,000 by the 2025-2026 school year. The new campuses include two in Humble.


What else I'm reading

It's not just people and drugs that U.S. Customs and Border Protection has to be on alert for at the border. The Border Report says agents, with the help of a drug-sniffing dog, found a keel-billed toucan and 21 parrots that a woman attempted to smuggle into the country in California. "Engaging in wildlife trafficking is illegal and can result in significant fines, imprisonment, and other legal penalties," said Rosa E. Hernandez, Port Director for the Otay Mesa and Tecate Ports of Entry.


More Newsletters

Houston to Arizona: Cougars Madness

Receive consistent coverage and updates about the Houston Cougars, as the team searches for its first NCAA title.

Houston Chronicle
Facebook Twitter Instagram YouTube LinkedInTikTok

Unsubscribe  |  Manage Preferences  |  Privacy Notice

Houston Chronicle - Footer Logo

Houston Chronicle
4747 Southwest Freeway, Houston, TX 77027
© 2024 Hearst Communications

No comments:

Post a Comment